Where was I saying these guys have turned into good players or made a good team? I just answered your clearly erroneous talking point that criticism of Mack Brown somehow ruined his recruiting efforts right away. How is it the critics' fault that some of them turned out to be thugs who break jaws of other student-athletes in bar ambushings (Cayleb Jones), guys who allegedly sexually assault women in dorms (Sanders, Meander), guys who can't pass piss tests (Estelle, Harrison), guys who got injured (Ash, Greenlea), or guys who didn't pan out, whether by being overrated or poorly coached up over their first three years.How did all of those high ranked recruiting classes work out on the field? Go down the list and see who actually played up to their star rankings. All of those recruiting rankings are for your entertainment. What the whole thing is really about is recruiting players who can actually play the game on the field. The last few classes that Mack got just did not pan out.
So I will call BS on you.
Your earlier premise that criticism of Mack Brown led to him not being able to bring in recruits is flat false, and instead of trying to change the subject, you should concede the point. 247sports wasn't alone in holding the 2011 and 2012 classes in such high regard. Rivals had them 3rd and 2nd. Scout had them 3rd and 1st. They were good classes that turned out to include some bad characters and that were poorly coached. You tell me how someone saying Mack Brown should be fired is responsible for any of that.
It isn't criticism of the coaches that has made Texas a bad team today. It is the inability of coaches to evaluate talent and character before the recruits arrive, inability of coaches to develop the talent, and inability of coaches to meld it into units that perform on the field. Some of that is on Mack Brown and his staff. Some of that is now on Charlie Strong and his staff. And yes, a lot, a very large lot of it is the youth of the team at present, and for that reason, I am willing to wait until the end of the year to judge the performance of the coach, and I think all of us should similarly wait to see if there has been progress.
Does an unhappy, carping fan base help? No, but the harm it does is insignificant compared to the poor performances shown on the field over long periods of time. On the list of things bothering a recruit, I also put tens of thousands of empty seats far ahead of hot criticism on message boards. At least the second shows care and concern about the state of the program. The former shows nothing but indifference.
Last edited by a moderator: