Welcome to the HornSports Forum

By registering with us, you'll be able to discuss, share and private message with other members of our Texas Longhorns message board community.

SignUp Now!

SI's Andy Staples on Franklin Barbecue

primal defense

Veteran
Joined
Nov 4, 2013
Messages
6,997
Also has an article on the aggies and Ricky Seal-Jones if you click on the link.

I probably shouldn’t write about brisket on the maiden voyage of a column called Punt, Pass & Pork. However, I was in Texas for much of last week, so the cow will horn its way into the discussion. Three years ago I visited Franklin Barbecue in Austin and declared it the best joint in America. I returned last week to see if that assessment should still stand.

When I visited in 2011, Franklin had moved into its current location from a trailer. The lines were long. I waited two hours for hunks of that tender, moist brisket seasoned with salt, pepper and magic and smoked over post oak. The pork spare ribs were juicy and pulled clean off the bone with the gentlest tug, and, though the meat didn’t need it, the espresso barbecue sauce was a treat.

The good news? Franklin still serves what might be America’s best brisket. The ribs remain strong. The espresso sauce is excellent. Franklin also now sells miniature pies from The Cake and Spoon, a bakery in Austin, and the banana bourbon can induce a bliss coma.

The bad news? Unlike most places, the lines didn’t die down after the initial surge of popularity. When I visited last week, I waited four and a half hours before eating. The brave souls in the front of the line arrived at 5:30 a.m., so they waited five and a half hours before eating. After finally getting inside and receiving my food, I performed a cost-benefit analysis as I chewed.

Yes, Franklin’s brisket is better than anyone else’s. But it’s not so much better that it is worth sacrificing four and a half hours of my life. (“That’s what interns are for,†a high muckety-muck at an Austin company told me the next day.) The brisket is nearly as good -- and the line much shorter -- at nearby la Barbecue. You could drive to Taylor, go to Louie Mueller and eat one of those beef ribs that looks like something Fred Flintstone would have delivered to his car and drive back to Austin

in less time. On a Saturday morning, you could drive to Snow’s in nearby Lexington -- because it is only open on Saturdays -- and have brisket almost as good for breakfast. Snow’s opens at 8 a.m., and despite several years of Franklin-like lines, it requires only a short wait for those who arrive early.

If you haven’t been to Franklin, you should absolutely go for the brisket and the experience. Bring some friends, some lawn chairs and a stocked, rolling cooler. If -- unlike me -- you’re a brunch person, it won’t feel much different. But if you’ve already been to Franklin, you’re probably better off exploring some of the famous nearby spots. If enough people do that, maybe the lines will die down at Franklin and those of us with less time on our hands will be able to get that brisket without sacrificing so much of our precious time on earth.

As for the No. 1 ranking, it’s up for grabs again. After visiting such stars as Pecan Lodge (Dallas), Heirloom Market (Atlanta), Rodney Scott BBQ (Hemingway, S.C.) and The Skylight Inn (Ayden, N.C.), I’ve realized more careful study will be required before we can name a national champ. Maybe we should form a committee and then hold a playoff to figure it all out.

http://www.si.com/college-football/2014/08/24/texas-am-tight-ends-punt-pass-pork

 
The bad news? Unlike most places, the lines didn’t die down after the initial surge of popularity. When I visited last week, I waited four and a half hours before eating. The brave souls in the front of the line arrived at 5:30 a.m., so they waited five and a half hours before eating. After finally getting inside and receiving my food, I performed a cost-benefit analysis as I chewed.
I love me some Texas BBQ, but I ain't waiting 4+ hours for anything.  Maybe Franklin's will open a bigger joint someday.

I'd love to try it, but refuse to wait longer than 30-45 minutes.

 
It is one of those things that you treat as an event. You go down there with 3-5 buddies with folding chairs and an ice chest and bullshit for a few hours.

 
It is one of those things that you treat as an event. You go down there with 3-5 buddies with folding chairs and an ice chest and bullshit for a few hours.
Like a tailgate?  Can you drink beer in that parking lot?

 
I had BBQ at Franklin's last week and I have had some great BBQ at other places. It was not worth the wait and Rudy's is even better. City Market is also better. I just do not get that you guys thinks Franklin is so good. The people that I went with have my same feelings.

 
I love me some Texas BBQ, but I ain't waiting 4+ hours for anything.  Maybe Franklin's will open a bigger joint someday.

I'd love to try it, but refuse to wait longer than 30-45 minutes.
Agreed. I want to try it and have for a while now, but I'll be damned if I sit out there that long.

 
I understand Mueller's in Taylor is comparable and uses the same recipe/process. Apparently, there is a family connection of some kind.

I've never eaten at Franklins but like you, I don't have 3.5-4.5 hours to blow for a bite to eat. I hate lines with a passion.

I've eaten at Black's in Lockhart and was mildly impressed.

To this day and without hesitation, I will say the best ribs I've ever had were at The Country Tavern in Kilgore, Texas. No lines. No menus. It's beer and ribs and no, they won't give out the recipe. It is a spiritual experience, no doubt.

Pecan Lodge in Dallas is pretty good, but even it falls far short of Country Tavern on the ribs.

 
Yes JB you can drink beer in the parking lot there. It's not any better than some of the other locals, in fact it was very mealy to me as though it had been wrapped and steamed to death, like a roast submersed in water in a crock pot. He dropped a new brisket on the board when it was my turn to order and it shook like a tub of jello, not good. All the texture was gone and it was mushy, mealy, gray colored and overrated IMHO. I'm fairly certain Louie Mueller ( where Aaron cut his teeth) uses a brick pit and Aaron uses a steel smoker so not similar in terms of process.

Like a tailgate?  Can you drink beer in that parking lot?
 
IF you want to go to Franklin's.. you don't have to wait in line...

170.gif


 
Back
Top Bottom