If you had the #1 pick, who would you roll with?

[Wes]

After seeing the players so far would you take Andrew Luck or RGIII?

I'd still go with Luck. His ability to shake off bad plays and come back and succeed in games is that of a super bowl winner. He also has elevated the worst team in football to a possible playoff team. And he's a rookie playing on a team that is not loaded with talent.

RGIII is still a great rookie QB. He's shown his athletic ability just like he was expected by those who thought he could be a monster at QB. But IMO Luck still has the edge, and it's because of his ability to shake off bad plays and make a few more throws than RGIII can.

 

[bbdude]

Dude, I would roll with Luck, no question. Even as a rookie he has surpassed expectations. RG3 gives you instant gratification with the running (and passing) game but Luck is the prototypical NFL passer. It is easy to see that he will lead the Colts to a SB or 2 a few years down the road. Kid is smart and unselfish.